The Pomona City Council will hear two appeals Monday, Nov. 16, involving the same North Garey Avenue property. One concerns whether seven oak trees can be removed. The other concerns whether the property at 898 N. Garey Ave. should retain its determination of historic significance.
On Oct. 28, the Planning Commission took up a permit application to remove seven oaks across the commercial parcels at 878–898 N. Garey Ave. The Council’s agenda says the commission approved the permit. The Council can uphold that decision or grant the appeal and deny the permit.
The Oct. 28 permit file lists an arborist report submitted by the applicant. Pomona’s oak preservation rules call for the City Arborist to review the application and make a recommendation before final approval. The attachment list does not establish whether the City Arborist reviewed this application or what they recommended.
Planning staff cited a Class 4 exemption under the California Environmental Quality Act, describing the work as a landscaping alteration. The exemption excludes removal of healthy, mature, scenic trees except for forestry and agricultural purposes. What evidence did staff use to determine that removing these seven oaks qualifies?
The city’s Oct. 28 meeting page lists published minutes as unavailable. The Nov. 16 Council packet lists the commission’s approved resolution.
The historic appeal is a separate decision. The Historic Preservation Commission determined that 898 N. Garey Ave. is historic. The Council can uphold that finding or overturn it. The agenda lists two appeals; it does not list a demolition permit for the building.
For residents, the questions before the vote are concrete: What evidence supports removing all seven trees? Could any remain? And what would reversing the historic finding change for future work at the property?
The hearings are listed together as Item 35. The public session starts at 7 p.m. in the Council Chambers at 505 S. Garey Ave. and online.
The Pomonan is an independent online magazine covering Pomona and the surrounding region.
