Lisa Lyon

Patti Davis, Playboy, Bush, Titties, and a Typewriter

In 1994, Ronald Reagan's daughter posed nude for Playboy. America had plenty to say about her tits. She was writing about sex, too, but the photographs were what caused the fuss.

I've been staring at Patti Davis's tits. Not continuously. I do have other things to do. But I have a copy of the July 1994 Playboy, and every time I look at the cover, I find myself returning to the same question. Did she decide to have her titties cupped by man hands? They're holding her breasts from behind. Two anonymous hands, carefully positioned, as if somebody in the art department worried that Davis might not know what to do with her own tits.

It's a strange photograph. Not especially erotic to me, although I can see the appeal. There's something almost clinical about the arrangement. The hands are doing the touching, Davis is doing the looking, and the person holding the magazine is presumably supposed to imagine himself somewhere in between. I wonder whether she liked the photograph, whether she laughed when she saw it, or whether the photographer said something ridiculous like, “Now give me sexy.”

Davis was 41 when she posed. She'd written books, had relationships, used drugs, gotten sober, and spent years lifting weights. She was a grown woman who wanted photographs of her naked body. Naturally, everybody wanted to know what her father thought. Her father happened to be Ronald Reagan, which gave the whole thing an additional layer of absurdity. People discussed the pictorial as though Davis had been caught masturbating in the Lincoln Bedroom. Which, frankly, would have been a much better scandal.

I keep imagining some conservative gentleman buying the magazine for research purposes. Perhaps he wanted to understand the decline of Western civilization. Perhaps he wanted to see whether the former president's daughter had nice nipples. Both interests could be satisfied for the price of one magazine.

The funny thing is that Davis had already written an erotic novel called Bondage. She wasn't suddenly discovering sex at 41. She'd been thinking about it, writing about it, and presumably having some of it. There was even an erotic story by Davis in the same issue, titled “Safe Sex.” That interests me more than the photographs. Not because writing is inherently more respectable than showing your pussy. I've read plenty of terrible erotic fiction, and I've seen nude photographs that deserved to hang in museums. Sometimes a photograph is more revealing than a memoir. Sometimes a sex scene tells you nothing about the person who wrote it.

But I like the idea of Davis sitting down to write something dirty while the rest of the country was busy discussing whether her father would be embarrassed by her breasts. I haven't read “Safe Sex” closely enough to tell you whether it's any good. I'd like to. I'm curious about the language. Whether she uses cock or penis. Whether the people in her story actually fuck or spend three pages describing the moonlight before anybody takes off their underwear.

Erotic writing can be awful that way. People will describe a woman's breasts as ripe fruit, a man's erection as a throbbing sword, and an orgasm as a spiritual awakening. Meanwhile, you're sitting there wondering whether anyone involved has ever had sex. I want to know whether Davis could write about desire without apologizing for it. I also want to know whether the editors at Playboy treated her writing with the same enthusiasm they had for her naked body. I suspect the photographs were the easier sell.

Davis later explained that she'd spent years rebuilding her body after addiction. She'd become fascinated with the bodybuilder Lisa Lyon and wanted to develop that kind of muscular strength herself. I find this a much more interesting explanation for the photographs than the idea that she wanted to humiliate her parents. She worked for that body. She liked what she'd made of it. She wanted somebody to photograph it before it changed. Fine by me.

I've never understood why people demand a philosophical explanation whenever a woman decides she wants to be seen naked. Maybe she likes her ass. Maybe she wants the money. Maybe she gets off on being watched. Maybe she wants photographs to look at when she's 80 and wondering where the hell her knees went. Maybe it's none of those things. Davis called the photographs her victory lap. I like that.

I don't particularly care whether posing for Playboy was empowering. That word has ruined more conversations about sex than a badly timed phone call from someone's mother. Playboy was a business. Davis was paid. Men bought the magazine. Some of them probably masturbated to the photographs. Others might have admired her muscles, read her fiction, or complained about her behavior while keeping the issue in a drawer. Human beings are capable of considerable hypocrisy, especially when they're horny.

And I'm not going to pretend Playboy was some benevolent institution devoted to celebrating women's bodies. Hugh Hefner figured out how to make a fortune selling naked women to men who liked to think of themselves as sophisticated. The interviews were good, though. What interests me is that Davis participated knowingly. She wasn't a teenager who'd wandered into a photographer's studio without understanding what Playboy was. She was 41. She had her reasons. The magazine had its reasons. The men buying it had theirs. I doubt they were all thinking about the same thing.

Today, of course, she could sell the photographs herself. She wouldn't necessarily need a magazine. She could put them behind a subscription, answer messages from strangers, and discover how many men confuse fifteen dollars a month with a relationship. I'm not sure that's an improvement. The technology is convenient. The men are still men.

I imagine Davis would have had a particularly interesting subscriber base. Reagan admirers, Reagan haters, men curious about her father, men curious about her body, and probably a few who wanted to ask whether she'd ever masturbated in the White House. I hope she would have charged extra for those questions.

There's another thing I like about Davis. She posed nude again years later, at 58, for More magazine. I find that appealing. Not in the obligatory inspirational way we're supposed to talk about older women who take off their clothes. I simply like that she was still interested in being naked.

I hope I never become one of those people who believes sex belongs exclusively to the young. I've met people in their twenties who seemed exhausted by the entire business and people in their sixties who were having a marvelous time. Age doesn't tell you nearly as much about desire as people think. Neither does a photograph.

I can look at Davis's breasts on that cover. I can notice the muscles, the expression, the peculiar arrangement of the hands. I can find the photograph sexy or awkward or both. What I can't tell from looking at it is what Davis was thinking. That's why I keep coming back to the story she wrote.

There's a woman in the magazine who wanted to show her body and put her sexual imagination into words. The public was perfectly happy to look at the first and largely uninterested in the second. Maybe the story is terrible. Maybe it's brilliant. Maybe it's the sort of thing you read once and forget. I'd still like to read it. I've already spent enough time looking at her tits.


Roux writes about sex, desire, culture and the things people are usually more comfortable doing than discussing for The Pomonan.